The internet is a-buzz with viral vids of kids' meltdowns when their iPads are wrestled away. But amidst all the scare talk of toddlers’ techno addiction, some experts believe a daily dose of technology is okay so long as screens are used the right way.
Children’s brain and technology researcher Dr Kristy Goodwin warns we should be careful of labelling kids as 'addicted' to devices. “In the vast majority of circumstances,” she says, “I don’t think young children, especially under the age of eight, can necessarily be addicted to technology. If we look at it as a dependence or an attachment, we can start to just look for small changes and ways in which we can help alter their behaviour.”
Listen to Kristy's interview with Kinderling Conversation:
Here's her advice for encouraging kids to use technology in a healthy and constructive way:
1. Look at how your kids use their screen time
“I actually don’t encourage parents to focus exclusively on the time metric. What I say to parents instead is look at your kids’ time on screen and consider is it time healthy and helpful? Is it helping to support some of [your child’s] basic needs or is it perhaps encroaching on some of their basic needs? So are they still having enough opportunities every day to sleep, to play, to be physically active, to hear and use language? Are they building relationships?”
“If they’re getting opportunities for those each day, I don’t think we necessarily have to fret about how much time they’re spending with a screen. But if we allow screen time to dominate those basic needs, that’s when I think we can get into trouble.”
2. Ditch your ‘techno guilt’
“I think if we’re really mindful and intentional about when we’re using technology, why we’re using it and how our kids are using it, there’s no need for us to feel guilty.”
“[Our kids] will inherit this digital world so I think one of our moral responsibilities as modern parents is to show kids how to use the technology in the right sorts of ways. And certainly having boundaries and rules around their use, but guiding them so that they can find the best ways to use it.”
3. Don’t dunk them in the digital stream too soon
“As a general rule, I say to parents be really cautious about dunking kids into the digital stream too prematurely, so before the age of two, about 15 to 20 minutes a day would be the maximum I’d recommend.”
“For two to five year-olds, I tend to agree with the Federal Government’s recommended guidelines for screen time. As a rough guide that’s an hour a day. But an hour with the TV is very different to an hour playing the iPad and creating a digital storybook. So we’ve really got to focus on what they’re doing as opposed to just exclusively looking at how much time they’re spending with devices.”
4. Avoid time limits for under-fives…
“I’m reluctant to recommend time limits, especially for children under five. Most children under the age of five don’t understand the concept of time, it’s very abstract. So saying ‘You’ve got 20 minutes on the iPad’ means absolutely nothing to them.”
“So with younger children under five, I often recommend a quantity, so a number of apps or a number of episodes of TV that they can watch. Something that is very specific and measurable for them as opposed to giving them a time metric.”
5. … but set parameters for over-fives
“If (kids) are older than five or they do in fact understand the concept of time, give them firm parameters before it’s switched on and then adhere to those. So using a clock, whether it’s on the device itself or on the microwave, but something that’s external so the child can start to see their elapsed time and enforcing those boundaries.”
“It’s one thing to come up with screen limits (and as a mum we often get side-tracked, and that concept of time disappears for us), but it’s important to enforce those limits and being consistent with that helps.”
6. Have a ‘succession plan’
“It's basically a transition activity. When kids are on the iPad their brain is often being flooded by lots of the neurotransmitter dopamine. They’re really engaged with what they’re doing so to say to your child ‘Come off and do your maths homework!’ or ‘Come and set the table!’ or ‘Go and tidy your toy room up!’ is really not an ideal transition activity.”
“So we want to basically entice our child off the technology, but with an activity that is either equally as pleasurable or rewarding because when we don’t do that, that’s when we often see the techno tantrum. They’re having literally those dopamine withdrawals.”
7. Let kids unplug themselves
“When we empower our children to turn off the technology, they feel like the locus of control is within them. It’s a really trivial gesture but for the child, they actually feel like they have some ownership over ending their time with the technology, as opposed to you yanking the remote control out of their hands or wrestling your iPhone back from them.”
“It’s also about rewarding them and encouraging them, praising them for when they do switch it off because you’ve caught that teachable moment. So it is simple but highly effective.”
Hear Kinderling Conversation every weekday at 12pm or grab the podcast
Save the snag: The humble sausage is under attack
We’ve shunted sugar. Wept over wheat. And ditched dairy. But for the love of all that is holy: lay off the sausage!
The top 22 kid-friendly places to eat in Australia
A go-to guide for family eats.
On the move: 3 travel essentials to make leaving home with kids easy
How to travel without the tears.
Mastering the juggle: Top tips from 5 experts to keep all your balls in the air
Practical ideas for getting on top of it all.
Why I’m calling for a truce on the war on sugar
Can the sugar police stop with their judgement please?
The 4 best toys to pack for travel with kids
Great off-screen activities to keep the kids entertained.
The top 3 baby sleep products as picked by parents
A good night's sleep doesn't have to be a pipe dream.
Out the door: Re-writing the script for chaotic mornings with kids
How to make the mornings a little bit calmer for all.